The Price of Citizenship: Increased Fees Loom for Green Card Holders

Updated: Mar 06, 2024 | Tags: U.S Naturalization, USCIS fee overhaul, Green Card

Over 9 million green card holders currently reside in the United States with the potential to become full-fledged American citizens. Yet, as of April 1st, a steep rise in naturalization application fees will make the path to citizenship even more expensive. 

This increase, part of a broader overhaul of USCIS fees that hasn't been seen since 2016, has immigration advocates warning that it could price many eligible immigrants out of the American Dream and prevent them from fully participating in the country they call home.

The Current State of U.S. Naturalization

Eligibility

To become a naturalized U.S. citizen, lawful permanent residents (green card holders) must meet several basic requirements.  

They must have lived in the United States for a continuous period of at least five years (or three years if married to a U.S. citizen), demonstrate good moral character, pass English and civics tests, and be able to read, write and speak basic English.

Pathway to Citizenship

Application Submission - The journey begins with filing Form N-400 (Application for Naturalization) and paying the required fees. Applicants must provide extensive personal information, documentation of residency, and other supporting materials.

Biometrics - Applicants are scheduled for a biometrics appointment where their fingerprints, photographs, and signature are collected.

Interview and Testing - A USCIS officer interviews the applicant, verifying information, and testing their English language skills and knowledge of U.S. history and government (civics).

Oath of Allegiance - Those who pass the interview and tests participate in a naturalization ceremony, taking the Oath of Allegiance to formally become U.S. citizens.

Benefits

Voting Rights

Perhaps the most fundamental right of citizenship is the ability to participate in the democratic process. U.S. citizens can vote in federal, state, and local elections. Their voices help determine who holds office and what policies shape their communities and the nation.  

Furthermore, citizens themselves are eligible to run for elected office, having a direct hand in shaping the laws and institutions that govern them.

Enhanced Travel Freedom

A U.S. passport opens doors around the world, offering visa-free or visa-on-arrival access to numerous countries. Citizens enjoy simpler border crossings and extended stays in many foreign nations.  

A U.S. passport also symbolizes greater protection when traveling abroad, as citizens have the right to consular assistance from U.S. embassies and consulates in case of emergencies.

Family Sponsorship

U.S. citizens can petition for certain family members to immigrate to the United States and obtain lawful permanent residency.  This includes spouses, children, parents, and siblings. 

Citizenship often means shorter wait times and a smoother process for family reunification.

The Changing Landscape of Fees

Historical Context

USCIS fees have a history of modification, reflecting the changing costs involved in providing immigration services. While past adjustments have sometimes been minor, larger fee increases have occurred periodically, significantly adding to the financial burden faced by immigrants seeking to legalize their status or become citizens. 

These past increases provide important context for the substantial changes set to take effect on April 1st.

Break Down the New Costs

The most significant change coming on April 1st is a steep rise in the cost of the N-400 application for naturalization. The base filing fee will rise substantially, representing a percentage increase of around 19%. 

This means that applicants will need to find hundreds of additional dollars on top of an already expensive process.  It's important to note that this change also impacts bundled applications that combine naturalization with other benefits. Additionally, some associated costs, such as those for biometrics, may also increase.

Rationale

The USCIS, a primarily fee-funded agency, claims the fee adjustments are essential to cover escalating operational expenses, necessary technological improvements, and the rising costs of providing immigration services. 

They justify the increases by citing factors like inflation, the growing backlog of applications, and the need to maintain adequate staffing to meet demand. However, critics of the fee changes argue that the increases are disproportionate and will have a devastating impact on low-income immigrant families striving for a better future.

Impact on Immigrants

Rising naturalization costs introduce a significant hurdle for immigrants seeking to become full participants in American society. The impact of these fees extends beyond simple economics, affecting individuals, families, and communities in several key ways:

Financial Strain

The rising cost of naturalization places a considerable financial burden on individuals and families who are often already living on tight budgets. For low-income immigrants, in particular, the fee increase could mean having to choose between essential expenses like food, rent, or healthcare and the pursuit of citizenship. 

This added financial strain could push the dream of becoming a U.S citizen out of reach for many.

Deferred Dreams

Even for those determined to save, the increased fees will likely prolong the path to citizenship. Immigrants could be forced to delay their applications for months or even years, with the uncertainty of further fee increases looming. 

These delays can have real consequences, postponing access to the full benefits, protections, and sense of belonging that citizenship offers.

Inequity

Fee increases disproportionately impact the most vulnerable immigrant communities.  Those with limited financial resources, lower levels of English proficiency, or complex immigration histories are likely to face the greatest obstacles.  

The price of citizenship, therefore, becomes a mechanism that exacerbates existing socioeconomic inequities within the immigrant population.

The Voice of Immigration Advocates

Arguments Against - Immigration advocates across the country have been vocal in their opposition to the fee increases. They argue that citizenship should be accessible to all eligible immigrants, regardless of their socioeconomic backgrounds. 

Raising the cost of naturalization, they maintain, creates an insurmountable barrier that undermines equity, civic participation, and the very promise of America as a land of opportunity.

Counterarguments - While acknowledging the challenges faced by many immigrants, some may counter these concerns by highlighting the availability of fee waivers for low-income individuals or by emphasizing USCIS's need to maintain financial stability. 

However, advocates insist that such counterarguments fail to address the broader systemic issues at play.

Solutions - Rather than simply opposing fee increases, immigration advocates are also proposing alternative solutions. These include tiered fee structures based on income, increased government funding to support immigration services, and expanding assistance programs to help applicants navigate the financial and logistical complexities of the process.

By the Numbers: The Wider Impact

While the full consequences of the April 1st fee increase are yet to be determined, historical trends and expert analysis offer a concerning picture of the potential impact. Past fee hikes have been linked to decreases in naturalization application rates, suggesting a clear connection between financial barriers and the ability to pursue citizenship.

Economists warn that discouraging naturalization could have long-term consequences for the U.S. economy. Studies indicate that naturalized citizens often bring entrepreneurial spirit, contribute significantly to the workforce, and bolster tax revenues.  

Furthermore, research suggests a link between naturalization and increased civic engagement. Therefore, higher costs could indirectly contribute to lower voter participation and a less representative democracy.

Crucially, the impact of fee increases is uneven.  Low-income immigrant communities, those with less English proficiency, and individuals facing complex immigration histories are likely to be most significantly affected.  

This raises concerns that the path to citizenship could become further divided, with access determined by financial means rather than an individual's potential contributions to American society.

What This Means for the Future of America

Rising naturalization fees threaten to create a chilling effect, discouraging eligible immigrants from applying for citizenship out of financial fear or frustration. This could lead to a decline in citizen participation in civic life.  

Fewer naturalized citizens could translate into decreased voter turnout, lower rates of political engagement, and a less representative democracy.

Over time, if significant numbers of immigrants remain unable to afford citizenship, it could impact the social and cultural fabric of the United States. A smaller pool of naturalized citizens may lead to reduced cultural exchange and potentially weakened connections between immigrant communities and the broader American society.

The Cost of Belonging

The upcoming fee hike for naturalization highlights the hefty price tag often attached to the idea of belonging in the United States. For millions of immigrants, the dream of full citizenship and participation is becoming increasingly expensive. 

The problem extends beyond mere dollars and cents. Fee increases threaten to entrench social inequities, diminish civic engagement, and erode the very notion of America as a nation built by immigrants. 

As the barriers to citizenship grow, the question remains: at what cost does America maintain its identity as a land of opportunity for all?